Featured Reviews
Zuiko Redding Cedar Rapids, IA

Twenty years ago when we first founded Cedar Rapids Zen Center (we're a Buddhist Temple), Church Mutual was about the only company that would insure an organization so small and new as we were. Our roof was damaged by the derecho that blew through Iowa in early August, and when I called I reached an agent almost immediately. I'd recommend Church Mutual to any religious organization needing insurance of any kind.

Donna Ambrose Executive Director Neighbor's Place Wausau, WI

I choose Church Mutual because they are a trusted partner – I’m not just a customer, but they’re truly invested in the work that I do and they truly want us to succeed.

Paul Carlotto Trustee First United Methodist Church of North Andover North Andover, MA

"If we had had something like Church Mutual’s sensor program a few years ago a lot of damage and time lost could have been avoided. Anything we can use as a forewarning is a good thing. It is another tool I can use to reduce risk at our church.  When Church Mutual came along with this program and offered it for free, it really was a no brainer."

Share your experience with us

Your loyalty as a Church Mutual customer is greatly appreciated. Please share your unique experience with us.


Lilydale First Baptist Church, Chicago, IL
Ebenezer Baptist Church, Atlanta, GA
The Center, Palos Park, IL
Faith Community Church, Wichita, KS

Anonymous, Associate Pastor Jackson Revival Center Jackson, MS Aug, 2021

I would probably say I've always been completely satisfied with professional service from Church Mutual.

Donna Ambrose, Executive Director Neighbor's Place Wausau, WI Aug, 2021

I choose Church Mutual because they are a trusted partner – I’m not just a customer, but they’re truly invested in the work that I do and they truly want us to succeed.

Anonymous, Senior Pastor Abilene Hope Chapel Abalone, TX Jul, 2021

It [The Claim Process] was prompt, accurate, and I was very satisfied.

David Wright, Trustee Chairman Carraway United Methodist Church Greensburrow, NC Jul, 2021

They [Church Mutual] were very professional, polite throughout the whole process and they extradited the matter very promptly. I thought everything was good.

Anonymous, President of Joint Board and Trustees Church of the Redeemer Moravian Church Dublan, OH Jul, 2021

They're [Church Mutual] very prompt, very caring they did an excellent job of following up. [The] communication makes it a lot easier when you're talking to a real person and they're available for a question afterward to get more information, so it was fine and excellent.

Jesse R. Booth, Executive Pastor Zoan Baptist Church Fredericksburg, VA Jun, 2021

[Church Mutual was] very fair and prompt, courteous, and caring. They are polite in everything. They are fair in replacement for loss and compensation for damages. They showed empathy and cared for our situation.

James Powell, Pastor Abundant Grace Church Dudley, NC Jun, 2021

Very efficient, fair, and the quote's always good. [Church Mutual's] response time is always excellent. The premiums are competitive, representatives always respond in a prompt, professional, and courteous manner.

Charles E. Moore, Steward/ Treasurer St. James African Methodist Episcopal Church Camden, AR Jun, 2021

They [Church Mutual] treated me well, they were just courteous, nice, and they asked the right questions. The claims adjuster came down and met with us, didn't take long, and was on time. I recommend them all the time at church meetings. I wish they did homeowners insurance. If you can sign up with them, they will take care of you.

Thomas Hightower, Deacon Mount Zion Missionary Baptist Church Hinesville, GA Jun, 2021

They [Church Mutual] are like angels from heaven. They were understanding during a time of crisis. There were no t's not crossed or i's that were not dotted.

Dr. Leon Threatt, Pastor and Chairman of the Board Christian Faith Center Charlotte, NC Jun, 2021

Very prompt and professional in every aspect. I've been very encouraged with the overall experience with Church Mutual, we have had them for many years and I have been pleased with the experience. Church Mutual has certainly been everything we have hoped for from an insurance company, met all our desired expectations for our people and our property.

Join the Conversation! Facebook LinkedIn Youtube Instagram

Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. (a stock insurer)
P.O. Box 357 | 3000 Schuster Lane | Merrill, WI 54452-0357
Telephone (800) 554-2642 or (715) 536-5577

© 2021 Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. All rights reserved. Protecting the Greater Good is a registered trademark of Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.

Church Mutual is a stock insurer whose policyholders are members of the parent mutual holding company formed on 1/1/20. S.I. = a stock insurer.