Tim Perkins, Minister Center Church of Christ Center, TX Oct, 2020

They just did the right thing.

Mick Huntley, Associate Pastor Midlands Bible Baptist Church Bellevue, NE Oct, 2020

We were satisfied with how they handled the claims situation and thankful for the coverage that they provided.

Zuiko Redding, Cedar Rapids, IA Sep, 2020

I'd recommend Church Mutual to any religious organization needing insurance of any kind.

Frank Kiraly, Church Elder Hungarian Reformed Church Trenton, NJ Sep, 2020

Extremely satisfied with the company and the claims process has always been fast and efficient therefore they are highly recommended.

Rev. Katherine Rose, Pastor First District Connectional Church York, PA Sep, 2020

Exceptional, very professional, friendly and polite. Handled our claim very well. I would highly recommend Church Mutual.

Kippie Castronovo, Merrill Gardens at Gilroy Gilroy, CA Sep, 2020

They are on top of everything. They get back to you in a matter of hours. They are email friendly which helps too.

Anonymous, Macedonia Baptist Church Arverne, NY Aug, 2020

I am pleased with the integrity of the organization. Very prompt in providing information.

Ann Henry, Trustee Bethel Second Baptist Church Las Cruces, NM Aug, 2020

Very satisfied...always courteous, always prompt in getting back to you, even with COVID-19 going on. I have not had any problems.

Anonymous, Rock Island Milan School District Rock Island, IL Aug, 2020

Church Mutual is awesome and you need to contact them.

Pam Gray, Marietta Alliance Church Marietta, GA Aug, 2020

They go above and beyond to meet our needs. We have been with them for many years and we have never been disappointed.

Janice, New Northside Baptist Church St. Louis, MO Aug, 2020

The reps are always very responsive, and I would definitely recommend them.

Jonathon Hunt, Lead Pastor Open Arms Community Church North Tonawanda, NY Aug, 2020

Awesome experience, even with the COVID-19 restrictions.

Anonymous, Bible Baptist Church Crystal River, FL Aug, 2020

In a time when you are always talking to computers, it was so nice to talk to a person who had compassion. It was so easy. I even had to check to make sure I was talking to an insurance company because they were so nice and understanding.

Anonymous, Dwelling Place Church Inc. Lutz, FL Aug, 2020

Extremely professional, prompt and considerate. I’ve dealt with a lot of insurance companies for 35 years of my ministry and Church Mutual is by far the best.

Dellwood Williams, Pastor Mount Zion Baptist Church Weymouth, NJ Jul, 2020

Very on time very professional and they will take care of their clients. Highly recommend them.

Walton Jones, Rector Episcopal Church of the Resurrection Starkville, MI Jul, 2020

Simple, quick, fair, courteous and professional. By far the best experience with an insurance company I have ever had.

Steve Rebert, Sr., Senior Pastor Emmanuel Baptist Church Winchester, VA Jun, 2020

I've pastored this church for 35 years and I've had Church Mutual for 35 years. It's been one of the good consistent things of this. I am very pleased with them.

Cherie, Office Administrator Unitarian Universalist Church of Las Cruces Las Cruces, NM Jun, 2020

They're a great company and they take good care of their clients. They make sure you feel valued and heard. They are prompt and courteous in settling claims.

Dave Sanders, Executive Director The Center Palos Park, IL Jun, 2020

The thing that sticks out to me the most about Church Mutual is they know who we are. [Our rep] comes here once or twice a year - he knows who I am personally, he knows what this facility is, and what we do. They care about who we are - that's priceless.

Claas Ehlers, Chief Executive Officer Family Promise Summit, NJ Jun, 2020

A partner for insurance should offer more than just quotes and coverage. We are very pleased to work with Church Mutual which provides expansive resources in education on a range of issues that help with risk mitigation and best practices. Church Mutual's willingness to engage with Affiliates in regional meeting, webinars, and videoconferences is a great value for all Affiliates.

Anonymous, Acelero Learning Center Racine, WI May, 2020

They were very helpful and they will call to make sure that you are getting the service you need. I am very satisfied since it is my first workers’ comp claim.

Anonymous, Glad Tidings Assembly of God Rugby, ND May, 2020

I had really good help with sending the claim. They were very quick with getting the claim settlement.

Pete Hypes, Pastor Mission Community Church Chester, VA May, 2020

Church Mutual works very hard to ensure great customer service. And we have had a great relationship throughout the time we've been covered by Church Mutual.

Anonymous, Business Manager First United Methodist Church Belton, TX Apr, 2020

We use Church Mutual, and we've been satisfied. One of the things that I was happy about was that the adjuster took the time to find us a cheaper catalytic converter, she cut the price almost in half.

Jerry Lanford, Pastor First Southern Missionary Baptist Church Porterville, CA Apr, 2020

We’ve been with them for a long time and we’re satisfied with their service. I like that I never had any problems. I've had the same representative for 13 -14 years.

David Madina, Pastor Iglesia De Dios De Las Cruces San Antonio, TX Apr, 2020

Great insurance company. Church Mutual is excellent.

Phil Bryant, Pastor Sandy Valley Baptist Church Warner Robins, GA Apr, 2020

Church Mutual has always gone above and beyond. Every claim we ever had has always been taken care of promptly and professionally.

Dr. Pauline Plummer, Executive Pastor Ambassadors For Christ Church Redford, MI Apr, 2020

They make it an easy process, they are informative and they have considered their customer's needs. They have thought out in advance the care their customers need therefore they provide great customer care. It results in great customer care when we find ourselves in need.

Anonymous, Member New Zion Missionary Baptist Church of Jackson Jackson, MS Apr, 2020

They’re a company that stands with their client. They make sure they take care of theirs, they were professional, excellent and I will not leave.

Cory Bledsoe, Executive Director Louisville Rescue Mission Louisville, KY Apr, 2020

Our experience with Church Mutual was excellent. Our account representative was honest, communicative and informative during the exploration process. We were happy to make a transition to Church Mutual because we felt like they offered the right coverage for our organization at a price point that allowed us to devote more resources to our cause while maintaining peace of mind about our coverage.

Anonymous, , OK Mar, 2020

Church Mutual Insurance goes above and beyond!

Anonymous, Treasurer Lamb of God Lutheran Church Wasilla, AK Mar, 2020

Church Mutual was extremely responsive, thorough and prompt. I'm extremely satisfied and I trust them completely.

Anonymous, Christ Church of Deliverance Providence, RI Mar, 2020

One of the greatest insurance companies I've ever dealt with.

Bobby Cole, Johnson Grove Baptist Church -, TN Mar, 2020

I've been with Church Mutual 20 years and I plan on staying.

Anonymous, First African Baptist Church Goldsboro, NC Feb, 2020

They [Church Mutual] were prompt and concerned about our loss. They responded immediately and effectively.

Felix Arroyo, General Treasurer Church of the Flame of Ministry Brooklyn, NY Feb, 2020

Excellent! You guys are the best so far. You guys are very good and prompt.

Anonymous, Salem Sayers Baptist Church Adkins, TX Feb, 2020

We have been so satisfied with Church Mutual that we don't even consider getting bids from anyone else because they're so good.

Rosalyn Jones-Thomas, Administrative Assistant Greater Faith Temple Church Elizabeth, NJ Jan, 2020

All you need to do is make one call and they [Church Mutual] are right on it. We have had their coverage for at least 10 years and they are great

Anonymous, Grace Baptist Church Peoria, IL Jan, 2020

Church Mutual went above and beyond. Their service was very much appreciated.

Mrs. Sonya Erickson, Director of Finance and Administration Green Lake Lutheran Ministries Spicer, MN Dec, 2019

They are professional and reliable. Highly recommend them. We've been satisfied for many years!

Marty Jacobs, Pastor East Athens Baptist Church Athens, GA Nov, 2019

Very professional. I wouldn't really bother with any other company. They were serving and protecting the church. Felt like they were trying to help us as much as possible.

Sherice Cotton, Certified Nurse Assistant Knowles Assisted Living Nashville, TN Oct, 2019

The company is very wonderful. They are very helpful and made sure I understood everything. The customer service was wonderful also.

Anonymous, Office Administrator Calvary Community Church Sumner, WA Oct, 2019

They [Church Mutual] are caring and they give you a lot of information. They have webinars and have access to programs. They respond quickly with their customer service.

Anonymous, Senior Pastor Kingsway Worship Center Kingsbury, NY Oct, 2019

They [Church Mutual] were the best ever and they were the cheapest in cost.

Anonymous, Pastor Prince of Peace Lutheran Church Shoreline, WA Oct, 2019

I love Church Mutual!

Dimitrios Kyritsis, Reverend Father The Greek Orthodox Cathedral of Denver Denver, CO Oct, 2019

Everything went smoothly, no complaints whatsoever.

Craig Gordon, Accountant U.S. Bahá'ís National Center Evanston, IL Sep, 2019

Very prompt, professional, communicative and all around, they just do their job. Whatever needed to be done was done and it didn't take long. It [claim] was handled so quickly. So, they actually met the time frame I had asked for.

Joanne Salus, Human Resource Manager Becket-Chimney Corners YMCA Becket, MA Aug, 2019

I highly recommend them, they are awesome!

Cynthia Marie Mielke, Teacher Racine Unified School District Racine, WI Jul, 2019

My experience was that Church Mutual was very respectful.

Albert Fleming, Chairman of Trustee Board Jerusalem Missionary Baptist Church Memphis, TN Jul, 2019

Great company to have your business or church involved with. They are very prompt and professional.

Join the Conversation! Facebook LinkedIn Youtube Instagram

Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. (a stock insurer)
P.O. Box 357 | 3000 Schuster Lane | Merrill, WI 54452-0357
Telephone (800) 554-2642 or (715) 536-5577

© 2021 Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. All rights reserved. Protecting the Greater Good is a registered trademark of Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.

Church Mutual is a stock insurer whose policyholders are members of the parent mutual holding company formed on 1/1/20. S.I. = a stock insurer.