COVID-19 Response & Recovery: Click here for updates and resources

Our commitment to Protecting the Greater Good® has helped us become the country’s leading insurer of religious organizations and a premier provider for other organizations that inspire and serve others. Learn more about us.

Safety news just for you
Safety news just for you

Click here to subscribe and read our blog today!

NEW smoke alarm notification technology
NEW smoke alarm notification technology

ALARM ALERT™ device notifies of potential fires

Reducing risk starts with you
Fall/Winter 2021 Risk Reporter available online

Reducing risk starts with you

For over a century, our purpose has remained clear — support our customers, keep them safe and help them continue to serve others.
This purpose will drive us for generations to come.


We proudly protect:

•Houses of worship
•Nonprofits and human services
•Public and private schools

•Camps and conference centers
•Senior living communities

From Our Customers

I recently submitted a claim for lightning damage to our church. My contact was Ms. Sanderson. She is very knowledgeable, extremely helpful and a great customer service individual. She has changed my opinion of insurance companies completely. There are so many insurance companies that could take lessons from Church Mutual.

Ron Holcomb, Trustee, La Grange First United Methodist Church
La Grange, TX — Nov. 2021

Easy, trustworthy, and they pretty much handled everything as soon as I contacted them. They [Church Mutual] told me what they needed, I got it to them, and they followed-up. It was handled very quickly.

Lindsey Farmer, Office Manager, Oak Hill United Methodist Church
Chandler, NC — Sep. 2021

That's why we stay with church mutual, so many companies try to get us to switch, but I won't switch. I'd say [we're] very satisficed.

John Thoroughgood, Trustee Chair, Grace United Methodist Church of Milsboro
Milsboro, DE — Sep. 2021

I would recommend them [Church Mutual]. They do good work and respond back in a timely manner.

Ruthie Pospicil, General Manager, Asbury Thrift Store Inc.
Madison, AL — Sep. 2021

They are very prompt, direct company and they will take care of you. They take care of all of your insurance needs and they don't cut any corners.

Loy Bowen, New Life Temple of Cassville
Cassville, MO — Aug. 2021

I'd recommend them [Church Mutual]. They're helpful, they followed through and they were on it. I didnt have to call a million times. They did what they said they were going to do.

Gerald Wiggins, Transportation Leader, Mount Zion Miracle Station SDA Church
Wilmington, DE — Aug. 2021

They [Church Mutual] were very helpful and timely. We experienced no problems getting what we needed done.

Betty C. Washington, Business Administrator, Plum Grove Baptist Church
Tuscaloosa, AL — Aug. 2021

Very efficient, very business-like, and very quick to respond to my questions, very courteous.

Phyllis Jeffers, Church Secretary, Raleighs Crossroads United Methodist Church
Greensboro, NC — Aug. 2021

They [Church Mutual] are very professional, compassionate people and everything was handled in a timely manner

Mark LaVonne, Head Trustee, St. Mark United Methodist Church of Opelousas
Opelousas, LA — Aug. 2021

I would probably say I've always been completely satisfied with professional service from Church Mutual.

Anonymous, Associate Pastor, Jackson Revival Center
Jackson, MS — Aug. 2021
Join the Conversation! Facebook LinkedIn Youtube Instagram

Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. (a stock insurer)
P.O. Box 357 | 3000 Schuster Lane | Merrill, WI 54452-0357
Telephone (800) 554-2642 or (715) 536-5577

© 2021 Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. All rights reserved. Protecting the Greater Good is a registered trademark of Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.

Church Mutual is a stock insurer whose policyholders are members of the parent mutual holding company formed on 1/1/20. S.I. = a stock insurer.