Hurricane Isaias:
If you were impacted by the storm, here's
key recovery considerations for the days and weeks ahead
Church Mutual Insurance
Insurance
By Industry
Houses of WorshipNonprofit & Human Services OrganizationsCamps, Sports & Outdoor RecreationEducation & Schools
By Coverage
Specialized CoverageProperty CoverageLiability CoverageWorkers’ Compensation
Resources
Risk Control
View AllChecklists & GuidesSafety ProductsVideos
Articles
View AllCamps, Sports, and Outdoor RecreationEducation and SchoolsHouses of WorshipNonprofit and Human Services
Partner Services
View AllNurse HotlineTelemedicineBackground Checks
Additional Resources
Customer CenterBroker CenterFAQs
Support
Get In Touch
ChatContact Options800-554-2642
Additional Support
Claims CenterPremium AuditPayment CenterFind Your Local RepBroker Center
About
Who We Are
Why Church MutualHistoryLeadershipTestimonialsCM CARES®Newsroom
Careers
Job OpeningsWorking HereCareer AreasDiversity & InclusionBenefitsEarly Career
pay a bill
Pay online:
Make A Payment
Visit our Payment Center for more info. We’ve upgraded our payment system. Read our FAQs for details.
File a Claim
Start Your Claim
Questions? Visit our Claims Center for more info.
Log In
Customer Accounts:
Customer Log In
CREATE ACCOUNT
Broker Accounts:
BROKER LOG IN
CREATE ACCOUNT
search
I’m looking for…
Questions? Check out our FAQs for more info.
Start a Quote
My organization is a
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Start a Quote
US flagChurch Mutual gives backUS flag
Checklists & Guides
Education & Schools
Nonprofit & Human Services Organizations
Houses of Worship
Camps Sports & Outdoor Recreation
Severe Weather Preparedness
Checklists & Guides
Education & Schools
Nonprofit & Human Services Organizations
Houses of Worship
Camps Sports & Outdoor Recreation
Severe Weather Preparedness
12/19/2019
Information

Hurricane Ready? Try a Tabletop Exercise to Find Out

Hurricane Ready? Try a Tabletop Exercise to Find Out

When a hurricane threatens, every second counts. High winds, flooding and mandatory evacuations can leave organizations scrambling unless they’ve prepared in advance. The challenge isn’t just having a Severe Weather Preparedness and Response Plan on paper, but knowing whether it actually works under pressure.

That’s where our Hurricane Tabletop Exercise comes in. This resource is designed to help leaders test their emergency response processes in a safe, simulated environment. By walking through realistic hurricane scenarios, your organization can identify weaknesses, strengthen communication and build confidence before disaster strikes.

‍Why a Tabletop Exercise Matters

Too often, organizations discover gaps in their emergency plans during the chaos of an actual storm. A tabletop exercise provides a low-risk way to evaluate readiness, giving your team a chance to rehearse decision-making, coordination and crisis communication.

The guide underscores the importance of bringing together a group—ideally fewer than 15 participants—to role-play through hurricane scenarios. Participants should not be the same people who created the emergency plan, ensuring fresh eyes and honest feedback.

What the Exercise Covers

The exercise unfolds in three phases—preparation, execution and conclusion—and provides detailed steps for each.

  • Preparation: Review your objectives, gather your team and ensure leadership is present to observe and evaluate. This phase also involves tailoring the scenario to your organization’s unique risks and needs.
  • Execution: Participants introduce themselves and their roles, then work through escalating hurricane scenarios. Each stage includes discussion questions that challenge the group to think critically about monitoring weather, securing facilities, safeguarding data and assisting vulnerable members.
  • Conclusion: Leadership helps review how the exercise went, identifying areas of strength and weakness. The guide encourages setting SMART goals (specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, timely) to address any gaps uncovered and planning follow-up exercises to track improvement.

Realistic Scenarios to Stress-Test Your Plan

The resource includes sample scenarios based on a fictional storm—Hurricane David—as it approaches and strengthens. In Part 1, the storm is still offshore but gaining power, requiring participants to decide how to prepare facilities and communicate with staff. In Part 2, the storm has become a Category 3, with a state of emergency declared and evacuations underway. Teams must now decide how to secure an unoccupied facility, protect data and assets and ensure communication with displaced staff and members.

These scenarios help uncover practical issues, such as:

  • Who makes critical decisions during escalating emergencies?
  • How do you balance safety with protecting property and records?
  • What procedures exist to support elderly or disabled members during evacuation?

Why Download the Full Guide?

This preview only scratches the surface. The complete Hurricane Tabletop Exercise provides step-by-step instructions, guided discussion prompts and evaluation methods your leadership team can use to ensure your emergency response plan is practical and effective.

Share this article with others:
FacebookLinkedinMailLink
URL copied to clipboard!
Explore more risk resources:
By Category
ArticlesChecklists &GuidesSafety ProductsVideos
By Organization
Camps, Sports & Outdoor RecreationEducation & SchoolsHouses of WorshipNonprofit & Human Service Organizations
By Topic
Buildings & GroundsBusiness PlanningCOVID-19 Response & RecoveryCybersecurityFinancial TipsFire Preparedness & PreventionInjury & Illness PreventionMaintenanceSecurity & Crime PreventionSevere Weather PreparednessSexual Abuse PreventionStaff & Volunteer Safety & ManagementTransportation SafetyTravel

Related Risk Management Articles

view all articles
Winter Storm and Freeze Preparedness GuideWinter Storm and Freeze Preparedness Guide

Winter Storm and Freeze Preparedness Guide

read the article
Arrow
CM Sensor 24/7 Temperature and Water Alert System FAQsCM Sensor 24/7 Temperature and Water Alert System FAQs

CM Sensor 24/7 Temperature and Water Alert System FAQs

read the article
Arrow
Providing Emergency Shelter and Living ArrangementsProviding Emergency Shelter and Living Arrangements

Providing Emergency Shelter and Living Arrangements

read the article
Arrow
Checklists & Guides
Education & Schools
Nonprofit & Human Services Organizations
Houses of Worship
Camps Sports & Outdoor Recreation
Severe Weather Preparedness

Hurricane Ready? Try a Tabletop Exercise to Find Out

A tabletop exercise can help you critique current processes and identify improvement areas. Use this exercise to evaluate hurricane preparedness.

When a hurricane threatens, every second counts. High winds, flooding and mandatory evacuations can leave organizations scrambling unless they’ve prepared in advance. The challenge isn’t just having a Severe Weather Preparedness and Response Plan on paper, but knowing whether it actually works under pressure.

That’s where our Hurricane Tabletop Exercise comes in. This resource is designed to help leaders test their emergency response processes in a safe, simulated environment. By walking through realistic hurricane scenarios, your organization can identify weaknesses, strengthen communication and build confidence before disaster strikes.

‍Why a Tabletop Exercise Matters

Too often, organizations discover gaps in their emergency plans during the chaos of an actual storm. A tabletop exercise provides a low-risk way to evaluate readiness, giving your team a chance to rehearse decision-making, coordination and crisis communication.

The guide underscores the importance of bringing together a group—ideally fewer than 15 participants—to role-play through hurricane scenarios. Participants should not be the same people who created the emergency plan, ensuring fresh eyes and honest feedback.

What the Exercise Covers

The exercise unfolds in three phases—preparation, execution and conclusion—and provides detailed steps for each.

  • Preparation: Review your objectives, gather your team and ensure leadership is present to observe and evaluate. This phase also involves tailoring the scenario to your organization’s unique risks and needs.
  • Execution: Participants introduce themselves and their roles, then work through escalating hurricane scenarios. Each stage includes discussion questions that challenge the group to think critically about monitoring weather, securing facilities, safeguarding data and assisting vulnerable members.
  • Conclusion: Leadership helps review how the exercise went, identifying areas of strength and weakness. The guide encourages setting SMART goals (specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, timely) to address any gaps uncovered and planning follow-up exercises to track improvement.

Realistic Scenarios to Stress-Test Your Plan

The resource includes sample scenarios based on a fictional storm—Hurricane David—as it approaches and strengthens. In Part 1, the storm is still offshore but gaining power, requiring participants to decide how to prepare facilities and communicate with staff. In Part 2, the storm has become a Category 3, with a state of emergency declared and evacuations underway. Teams must now decide how to secure an unoccupied facility, protect data and assets and ensure communication with displaced staff and members.

These scenarios help uncover practical issues, such as:

  • Who makes critical decisions during escalating emergencies?
  • How do you balance safety with protecting property and records?
  • What procedures exist to support elderly or disabled members during evacuation?

Why Download the Full Guide?

This preview only scratches the surface. The complete Hurricane Tabletop Exercise provides step-by-step instructions, guided discussion prompts and evaluation methods your leadership team can use to ensure your emergency response plan is practical and effective.

Related Risk Management Videos

view all videos
Severe Weather PreparednessSevere Weather Preparedness

Severe Weather Preparedness

Watch the Video
Arrow
Checklists & Guides
Information
Safety Products are NO COST for Church Mutual customers.

Hurricane Ready? Try a Tabletop Exercise to Find Out

A tabletop exercise can help you critique current processes and identify improvement areas. Use this exercise to evaluate hurricane preparedness.

first-time enrollment
order additional devices
Order In Portal
Hurricane Ready? Try a Tabletop Exercise to Find Out

Related Risk Management Safety Products

view all safety products
CM Wildfire Solutions™CM Wildfire Solutions™

CM Wildfire Solutions™

Learn More & Order
Arrow
CM Sensor® 24/7 Temperature and Water Alert SystemCM Sensor® 24/7 Temperature and Water Alert System

CM Sensor® 24/7 Temperature and Water Alert System

Learn More & Order
Arrow
Checklists & Guides
Education & Schools
Nonprofit & Human Services Organizations
Houses of Worship
Camps Sports & Outdoor Recreation
Severe Weather Preparedness

Hurricane Ready? Try a Tabletop Exercise to Find Out

A tabletop exercise can help you critique current processes and identify improvement areas. Use this exercise to evaluate hurricane preparedness.

download now
open in a new tab
Hurricane Ready? Try a Tabletop Exercise to Find Out

When a hurricane threatens, every second counts. High winds, flooding and mandatory evacuations can leave organizations scrambling unless they’ve prepared in advance. The challenge isn’t just having a Severe Weather Preparedness and Response Plan on paper, but knowing whether it actually works under pressure.

That’s where our Hurricane Tabletop Exercise comes in. This resource is designed to help leaders test their emergency response processes in a safe, simulated environment. By walking through realistic hurricane scenarios, your organization can identify weaknesses, strengthen communication and build confidence before disaster strikes.

‍Why a Tabletop Exercise Matters

Too often, organizations discover gaps in their emergency plans during the chaos of an actual storm. A tabletop exercise provides a low-risk way to evaluate readiness, giving your team a chance to rehearse decision-making, coordination and crisis communication.

The guide underscores the importance of bringing together a group—ideally fewer than 15 participants—to role-play through hurricane scenarios. Participants should not be the same people who created the emergency plan, ensuring fresh eyes and honest feedback.

What the Exercise Covers

The exercise unfolds in three phases—preparation, execution and conclusion—and provides detailed steps for each.

  • Preparation: Review your objectives, gather your team and ensure leadership is present to observe and evaluate. This phase also involves tailoring the scenario to your organization’s unique risks and needs.
  • Execution: Participants introduce themselves and their roles, then work through escalating hurricane scenarios. Each stage includes discussion questions that challenge the group to think critically about monitoring weather, securing facilities, safeguarding data and assisting vulnerable members.
  • Conclusion: Leadership helps review how the exercise went, identifying areas of strength and weakness. The guide encourages setting SMART goals (specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, timely) to address any gaps uncovered and planning follow-up exercises to track improvement.

Realistic Scenarios to Stress-Test Your Plan

The resource includes sample scenarios based on a fictional storm—Hurricane David—as it approaches and strengthens. In Part 1, the storm is still offshore but gaining power, requiring participants to decide how to prepare facilities and communicate with staff. In Part 2, the storm has become a Category 3, with a state of emergency declared and evacuations underway. Teams must now decide how to secure an unoccupied facility, protect data and assets and ensure communication with displaced staff and members.

These scenarios help uncover practical issues, such as:

  • Who makes critical decisions during escalating emergencies?
  • How do you balance safety with protecting property and records?
  • What procedures exist to support elderly or disabled members during evacuation?

Why Download the Full Guide?

This preview only scratches the surface. The complete Hurricane Tabletop Exercise provides step-by-step instructions, guided discussion prompts and evaluation methods your leadership team can use to ensure your emergency response plan is practical and effective.

download now
open in a new tab

Related Risk Management Checklists & Guides

view all checklists & guides
10 Essentials of Severe Weather PreparednessHurricane Ready? Try a Tabletop Exercise to Find Out

10 Essentials of Severe Weather Preparedness

Get the Guide
Arrow
What You Need To Know About Windstorms For ProtectionHurricane Ready? Try a Tabletop Exercise to Find Out

What You Need To Know About Windstorms For Protection

Get the Guide
Arrow
React Quickly to Flooding and Hail: Protect Your FacilityHurricane Ready? Try a Tabletop Exercise to Find Out

React Quickly to Flooding and Hail: Protect Your Facility

Get the Guide
Arrow
Church Mutual Insurance
Facebook
LinkedIn
Youtube
Instagram
800-554-2642
Quick Links
Request a QuotePay a BillFile a ClaimFind Your Local Rep
Get Answers
Contact UsClaims CenterPayment CenterCustomer CenterBroker CenterNewsroom
Careers
Job OpeningsWorking HereCareer AreasDiversity & InclusionBenefitsEarly Career
Site Map
|
Consent Preferences
|
Legal & Privacy Policy

Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. (a stock insurer) | P.O. Box 357 | 3000 Schuster Lane | Merrill, WI 54452-0357 | Telephone (800) 554-2642 or (715) 536-5577
© 2026 Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. All rights reserved. Protecting the Greater Good is a registered trademark of Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.

¹ Church Mutual is a stock insurer whose policyholders are members of the parent mutual holding company formed on 1/1/20. S.I. = a stock insurer.