Kenneth Brock, President-Pastor New Welcome Baptist Church Detroit, MI Jul, 2018

Leave where they are [currently insured] at and come to Church Mutual.

Margie Fiedler, Executive Director Flathead Lutheran Bible Camp Kalispell, MT Jul, 2018

Efficient, and prompt. Available all the time. Good customer relations. Very professional. Very helpful. They really went out of the way to help us.

Neal Peek, Chairman of the Trustees Oak Hill United Methodist Church Cameron, NC Jul, 2018

You can't go wrong with Church Mutual.

Diana Ogden, Pastor New Beginnings Ministries Buckhannon, WV Jul, 2018

One of the best places to get insurance for your church.

Levon Weaver, Business Administrator Community Christian Church Kansas City, MO Apr, 2018

I love you guys!

Lawrence Hoskins, Pastor Tabernacle Holiness Church Beloit, WI Mar, 2018

Very punctual. The claim was handled quickly. Didn't have to wait a long time; everything was taken care of to my satisfaction. I would recommend them to another organization. I have been with them for years and have dealt with them with other types of claims than car insurance, such as water damage. Good insurance as far as I'm concerned and would recommend to anyone.

John Cardillo, Conference Treasurer & Director of Admin Svcs United Methodist Church of Greater New Jersey Neptune, NJ Feb, 2018

Our partnership with Church Mutual has been excellent. Our relationship began with them writing our Workers Compensation insurance and grew to insuring all of our churches. Their cost, coverage and care for our churches has proven to be very reliable. This is a relationship we truly appreciate.

Diane Yerks, Assistant Business Manager Promiseland Church Austin, TX Dec, 2017

They are prompt and responsive and they are everything I would expect from an insurance company. No hassles, and easy to get a hold of people. For an insurance company, it was a great experience.

William Ruffle, Assistant Saint Matthews Lutheran Church Willmington, NC Nov, 2017

It [claim] was handled I believe very efficiently with a lot of consideration and care for me. It was not just about numbers, I got what I should have in return for the service.

Katie Donegan, Book Keeper Garner Creek Retreat Center Dickson, TN Nov, 2017

The customer service is great, everyone is easy to talk to on the phone, timing was very prompt. We do like that there isn't a lot of paperwork, Church Mutual handles all of that.

Vernice Schultz, St. John's Lutheran Church Loganville, WI Oct, 2017

They do what they say they are going to do and are one of the cheapest.

Brittany Buchannan, Business Office Manager Meridian Senior Living Santa Monica, CA Oct, 2017

Just easy. It was an easy process and they made sure they get back to us as fast as possible.

Reverened Donald Pryor, Pastor Foothills Christian Center Palo Cedro, CA Oct, 2017

They are very smooth, very professional. The claim in general was very well handled. I would highly recommended to any church.

Tyrone Miller, Deacon Fairview Baptist Church Gretna, VA Jun, 2017

They are a great insurance company and have been great to the church... they answer questions and do whatever is needed.

Adell Quinn, Treasurer and Trustee Christ Temple Church Of Personal Experience Boston, MA Jun, 2017

They are trustworthy and conducted business thoroughly, and quickly. They explained everything. We had very big insurance companies, and Church Mutual was superior.

Celeste Scott, Teacher First Choice Childcare Lexington, KY Jun, 2017

Everything went was expedient, and they were helping and friendly and there could have been no company better to help us.

Lester Stronther , Chairman of Finance and Deacon's Ministry First Bethesda of God Summerville, SC Jun, 2017

It was perfect.... it was very professional....and she was really courteous and not in any hurry.

Rev. Craig Moock, Senior Pastor Rural Chapel UMC Galena, OH Apr, 2017

I have been really happy with Trusted Employees as our background check provider.  You [Church Mutual] having them as a preferred provider made a huge difference in us getting background checks up and running.  Their [Trusted Employees] web portal where the individuals being checked can fill out their info themselves saves tons of time and is very convenient. 

Johnnie Maschhoff, Director of Human Resources Immanuel Southern Baptist Church Ridgecrest, CA Mar, 2017

We had wind damage to our outdoor playground for children and Church Mutual was extremely timely in getting it done [claim]. They got right on the program.

Polly Floyd, Director of Business Affairs The Baptist College of Florida Graceville, FL Feb, 2017

They always exceed my expectations. They have fast service and courteous claim representatives, and they have our best interest in mind when they are taking care of the claim.

John Swiers, Trustee Strawberry Lake Mennonite Church Ogema, MN Feb, 2017

They were excellent, satisfactory, and perfect. They were excellent in the way they cared, handled it [our claim] and the payout.

Jim Taylor, Administrator Antioch Church of Christ Antioch, TN Feb, 2017

They are very professional and prompt. I have told people that in the 30 years I have worked here, they are the largest company that insures churches and camps, and their customer service could not be any better.

Richard L. Benson, Organist First Presbyterian Church Peotone, IL Jan, 2017

They were effective and very consistent in their reactions to any concerns. They serve the institutions well, based on my experience with them.

James Latham, Pastor New Testament Christian Church Springfield, MO Jan, 2017

They were professional and looked for every avenue possible to make sure we got the most out of our claim.

Rev. Larry Jones, Senior Pastor New Hope Pentecostal Holiness Church Newport News, VA Jan, 2017

The service was prompt and they were willing to listen to whatever our situation was. That is why we have been with them [Church Mutual] for forty years.

Gary P., Finance Elder Trabuco Presbyterian Church Trabuco, CA Jan, 2017

They have always been extremely responsive and sent someone whenever it was needed. They also review our policy in person every year to find ways to increase our coverage and lower our premiums.

Bryan Peterson, Pastor Ridgeway Church Madison, WI Jan, 2017

We've been around for 65 years, and I have been here for 26 years. Our relationship with Church Mutual has always been a good one.

Paul Carlotto, Trustee First United Methodist Church of North Andover North Andover, MA Dec, 2016

If we had had something like Church Mutual’s sensor program a few years ago a lot of damage and time lost could have been avoided. Anything we can use as a forewarning is a good thing. It is another tool I can use to reduce risk at our church.  When Church Mutual came along with this program and offered it for free, it really was a no brainer.

Gary F. Schluter, President Our Redeemer Lutheran Church and Preschool Chanhassen, MN Nov, 2016

On behalf of the congregation, I would like to express thanks and appreciation to Church Mutual for efficiently handling this claim, and for your generous time allowance for completing the repairs.

Tom Igler, Minister Gospel Assembly Church Sperry, OK Nov, 2016

The Church and myself wish to express our very highest regards to yourself and Church Mutual for mediation and the horrific burden you bore to see us thru this tragic situation.

Mike Greene, Facilities Manager Saint Paul United Methodist Church Columbus, GA Nov, 2016

I am writing to thank you and your company for your service to our church over the last few years. The manner in which you assisted us through the trying times was over and above the call of duty. Often, large companies do not look out for the little guy and we are grateful that you did look out for us.

Sandy Theiss, Business Manager The United Methodist Church in Northern Virginia Alexandria, VA Nov, 2016

Just wanted to put in writing how much I appreciate all that your do for this office. With two districts and all the individual programs that we have under our umbrella, we do seem to generate a lot of questions. You have always been prompt in returning our phone calls; given me what information is needed in the form needed; and most gracious in responding to all my concerns. Thank you for being so approachable and for doing your job so well.

Gayle Steward, Secretary Hobart Baptist Church Pampa, TX Nov, 2016

We want to thank you for all your hard work regarding our burglary. We feel you have gone above and beyond the requirements of your job to help us. You have been so friendly and informative with us and we appreciate all you have done. We are blessed to have you and Church Mutual in our corner.

Dr. Alvan N. Johnson Jr., Reverend Bethel A.M.E. Church Bloomfield, CT Nov, 2016

This is just a note to share with you how thoroughly pleased we are with all of the services we are receiving from Church Mutual Insurance. The service has been courteous and professional. Our needs have been attended to extremely promptly. We feel fortunate and blessed to have this relationship.

Marilyn Gripe, Treasurer West Golden Wesleyan Church Mears, MI Nov, 2016

Very efficient and very satisfactory with their service and couldn't ask for better service through the years.

Della Harris, Financial Secretary Colossian Baptist Church Newport News, VA Nov, 2016

We have been a member of the Church Mutual family for many years. The funds were made available to us quickly. The deductible was clear on our policy. We have always been pleased with the way Church Mutual handles our insurance. We are very satisfied with Church Mutual.

Barbara Sullivan, Owner Tower View Villa Rosendale, WI Nov, 2016

Very professional. They are there when you need them and walk you through everything and were there to help me.

Anonymous, Chairman of Trustees First Baptist Church Rainelle, WV Oct, 2016

Church Mutual was very prompt and fair in the estimate and very quick. Whenever I had a question they answered it quickly.

Join the Conversation! Facebook LinkedIn Youtube Twitter

Church Mutual Insurance Company
P.O. Box 357 | 3000 Schuster Lane | Merrill, WI 54452-0357
Telephone (800) 554-2642 or (715) 536-5577

© 2018 Church Mutual Insurance Company. All rights reserved. Protecting the Greater Good is a registered trademark of Church Mutual Insurance Company.