Church Mutual Insurance Company

The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America selects Church Mutual as the Official Underwriter of the ELCA-Endorsed Property and Liability Insurance Program.

The decision to move the ELCA-Endorsed Property and Liability Insurance Program to Church Mutual was based on providing ELCA congregations and synods with quality insurance protection and enhanced customer service.

Church Mutual currently insures the ELCA Churchwide Office, all nine ELCA regional offices, 47 synods and more than 3,300 ELCA congregations.

Altogether, Church Mutual insures more than twice as many religious organizations as any other insurance company. The company offers an unmatched combination of size, financial strength and worship center expertise. 

Learn more, download our brochure (pdf)

We receive many positive comments from our existing ELCA customers — just like this one:

“In Church Mutual we have experienced a partner that delivers excellent service while providing a needed and valuable product to our congregations and synods.”

Wm. Chris Boerger
ELCA Secretary

Added value for our policyholders

Church Mutual policyholders should make sure to review our safety materials, designed specifically for churches. All are available at no cost to customers.

If you're not a Church Mutual policyholder, Request a Quote — at no cost and with no obligation — to compare your present insurance coverage with specialized coverage from Church Mutual.


Church Mutual Insurance Company
P.O. Box 357 | 3000 Schuster Lane | Merrill, WI 54452-0357
Telephone (800) 554-2642 or (715) 536-5577
Copyright 2017

Church Mutual Insurance Co. BBB Business Review Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Youtube