Featured Reviews
Myron Heckman Pastor Cape Cod Bible Alliance Church Brewster, MA

3:00 am is almost never a good time for the phone to ring, and when it rang at that time at Pastor Myron Heckman’s home, the bad news was the fire department was on the way to the Cape Cod Bible Alliance Church. It turned out the blaze had engulfed much of the church quickly as the result of an arsonist (who was soon caught). The Brewster, MA building was burned to the foundation.
Read More »

Paul Carlotto Trustee First United Methodist Church of North Andover North Andover, MA

"If we had had something like Church Mutual’s sensor program a few years ago a lot of damage and time lost could have been avoided. Anything we can use as a forewarning is a good thing. It is another tool I can use to reduce risk at our church.  When Church Mutual came along with this program and offered it for free, it really was a no brainer."

Rev. Larry Jones Senior Pastor New Hope Pentecostal Holiness Church Newport News, VA

"The service was prompt and they were willing to listen to whatever our situation was. That is why we have been with them [Church Mutual] for forty years."

Kenneth Brock, President-Pastor New Welcome Baptist Church Detroit, MI Jul, 2018

Leave where they are [currently insured] at and come to Church Mutual.

Margie Fiedler, Executive Director Flathead Lutheran Bible Camp Kalispell, MT Jul, 2018

Efficient, and prompt. Available all the time. Good customer relations. Very professional. Very helpful. They really went out of the way to help us.

Neal Peek, Chairman of the Trustees Oak Hill United Methodist Church Cameron, NC Jul, 2018

You can't go wrong with Church Mutual.

Diana Ogden, Pastor New Beginnings Ministries Buckhannon, WV Jul, 2018

One of the best places to get insurance for your church.

Levon Weaver, Business Administrator Community Christian Church Kansas City, MO Apr, 2018

I love you guys!

Lawrence Hoskins, Pastor Tabernacle Holiness Church Beloit, WI Mar, 2018

Very punctual. The claim was handled quickly. Didn't have to wait a long time; everything was taken care of to my satisfaction. I would recommend them to another organization. I have been with them for years and have dealt with them with other types of claims than car insurance, such as water damage. Good insurance as far as I'm concerned and would recommend to anyone.

John Cardillo, Conference Treasurer & Director of Admin Svcs United Methodist Church of Greater New Jersey Neptune, NJ Feb, 2018

Our partnership with Church Mutual has been excellent. Our relationship began with them writing our Workers Compensation insurance and grew to insuring all of our churches. Their cost, coverage and care for our churches has proven to be very reliable. This is a relationship we truly appreciate.

Diane Yerks, Assistant Business Manager Promiseland Church Austin, TX Dec, 2017

They are prompt and responsive and they are everything I would expect from an insurance company. No hassles, and easy to get a hold of people. For an insurance company, it was a great experience.

William Ruffle, Assistant Saint Matthews Lutheran Church Willmington, NC Nov, 2017

It [claim] was handled I believe very efficiently with a lot of consideration and care for me. It was not just about numbers, I got what I should have in return for the service.

Katie Donegan, Book Keeper Garner Creek Retreat Center Dickson, TN Nov, 2017

The customer service is great, everyone is easy to talk to on the phone, timing was very prompt. We do like that there isn't a lot of paperwork, Church Mutual handles all of that.

  • Awards

    Awards and accreditations for Church Mutual.

    Read More »
Join the Conversation! Facebook LinkedIn Youtube Twitter

Church Mutual Insurance Company
P.O. Box 357 | 3000 Schuster Lane | Merrill, WI 54452-0357
Telephone (800) 554-2642 or (715) 536-5577

© 2019 Church Mutual Insurance Company. All rights reserved. Protecting the Greater Good is a registered trademark of Church Mutual Insurance Company.