For Brokers/Agencies

Church Mutual Broker/Specialty Markets Division

As the leading insurer of religious organizations in America, Church Mutual now partners with elite brokers who have experience in the religious market and relationships with large religious accounts or affinity programs.

We are committed to providing direct access to key personnel so brokers and agencies can offer their customers the best products and service, all backed by our long history of financial strength.


Why work with Church Mutual?

By becoming one of Church Mutual’s select brokers or agents, you’ll experience the benefits of:

• 114 years of experience in the religious market

• A brand trusted by religious organizations nationwide

• Specialized and easy-to-work-with underwriters and other insurance specialists

• Limited appointments of other brokers and agents

• Profitable, strategic, methodical, and careful growth

Specialized coverages

In addition to property, general liability, commercial automobile liability, workers’ compensation and umbrella liability insurance, we also offer our customers special liability coverages for:

• Sexual misconduct/molestation

• Directors, officers and trustees

• Educators’ liability

• Employee benefits programs

• Counseling

• Employment practices to cover sexual harassment, discrimination and wrongful termination

• Corporal punishment

• Incidental medical services liability

For our appointed brokers and agencies

Basic coverage forms (log-in information required)

How to make a submission


How to become an appointed broker or agency

Interested brokers and agencies should contact Mark Steinberg at (800) 554-2642, extension 4124 or msteinberg@churchmutual.com.



Church Mutual Broker/Specialty Markets Division

Mark Steinberg, CPCU, AAI Assistant Vice President - Broker/Specialty Markets msteinberg@churchmutual.com (800) 554-2642 Ext. 4124	Matt Boyle, CPCU, CPA, CIA Director - Broker/Specialty Markets Operations mboyle@churchmutual.com (800) 554-2642 Ext. 4834
Rod Flanders, CPCU, CLU, ARM, CEBS, Fellow-ISCEBS Director - Agency Operations rflanders@churchmutual.com (800) 554-2642 Ext. 4117	Norm Hardy Territory Manager nhardy@churchmutual.com (817) 917-3618
Carin Mulvey Territory Manager cmulvey@churchmutual.com (716) 903-8500	Jerry Bellin, CPCU Broker/Specialty Markets Underwriter gbellin@churchmutual.com (800) 554-2642 Ext. 4224
Todd Griffith, CPCU Broker/Specialty Markets Underwriter tgriffith@churchmutual.com (800) 554-2642 Ext. 4797	Carrie Klinger Broker/Specialty Markets Support Specialist cklinger@churchmutual.com (800) 554-2642 Ext. 4245
Sherri Pehlke Broker/Specialty Markets Senior Support Specialist spehlke@churchmutual.com (800) 554-2642 Ext. 4784	Gina Kranz Broker/Specialty Markets Service Coordinator gkranz@churchmutual.com (800) 554-2642 Ext. 4890
Marty Heyne Director - Affinity Sales mheyne@churchmutual.com (800) 554-2642 Ext. 4930	Donna Pederson, AINS, AIS, CC, CPIW Affinity Sales Liaison dpederson@churchmutual.com (800) 554-2642 Ext. 4826